Maybelline vs. L'Oreal vs. Milani: Which Liquid Lip Actually Lasts All Day? ⏳
I have ruined too many white coffee mugs. ☕ There is nothing worse than applying a stunning bold lip in the morning, only to look in the mirror at 11 AM and see a blurry, faded ring around your mouth.
I went on a mission to find the "Holy Grail" of drugstore liquid lipsticks. I wanted something that wouldn't budge through a salad, wouldn't dry my lips into a raisin, and didn't cost a fortune. I tested 5 top contenders to see which one actually survives real life.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. All reviews are based on personal experience and not professional advice. Results may vary.
Why These Ingredients Matter 🧪
If you've ever wondered why some lipsticks slide off while others stick like glue, it comes down to two main components: Volatile Solvents (like Isododecane) and Film Formers.
The solvents allow the product to glide on liquid, but they evaporate quickly once they hit the air. This leaves behind the film formers, which create that flexible, transfer-proof shield over your lips. The trick is finding a balance—too much film former can feel like plastic, but too little means it wipes right off.
👉 Read Next: Looking to complete your look? Check out my top 5 lipsticks for every occasion.
⚡ Quick Look: The Winners
- Maybelline Sensational: Best Everyday Nude.
- L'Oreal Infallible: Most Comfortable Matte.
- Milani Amore Matte: Best Pigment (One Swipe).
- Revlon ColorStay: Best Durability (Bulletproof).
- Essence 8H Matte: Best Budget Find.
1. Maybelline New York Sensational Liquid Matte (Nude Nuance) 🍂
Best for Daily Wear 🏆
I honestly think "Nude Nuance" is the most universal shade Maybelline has ever created. It’s this perfect brownish-nude that suits almost every skin tone. I found the applicator surprisingly precise—it's small and doe-footed, which helps get those crisp edges without a liner.
The formula is thin. I noticed it dries down almost instantly, which is great if you are in a rush, but it means you have to work fast. It feels lightweight, almost like you aren't wearing anything, but after about 4 hours, I did feel a little dryness kicking in.
| ✅ Pros | 🛑 Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
2. L'Oreal Paris Infallible Matte Resistance (Lazy Sunday 150) ☁️
Best Comfort Matte 💄
If you hate that tight, "shrink-wrapped" feeling of liquid lips, this is the one for you. L'Oreal claims this has Hyaluronic Acid, and I actually believe them. I tested "Lazy Sunday," which is a stunning cool-toned pink.
The texture is "powdery" rather than watery. When I rubbed my lips together, it felt soft, not sticky. It survived my morning coffee completely intact. It eventually wore off in the center after a greasy burger, but it faded gracefully rather than flaking off in chunks.
| ✅ Pros | 🛑 Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
👉 Related: Speaking of long-wear beauty, check out my list of chip-resistant nail polishes.
3. Milani Liquid Lipstick The-Moment (Matte) 🎨
Best Color Payoff 🌈
Milani does not mess around with pigment. "The Moment" is a deep, rich shade that applies fully opaque in literally one swipe. I noticed this one smells like vanilla frosting, which I loved!
This formula locks down hard. Once it’s dry, it is not moving. I kissed my hand firmly and there was zero transfer. However, because it seals so tightly, I did feel my lips getting dry after about 6 hours. You definitely need a good remover oil to get this off at night.
| ✅ Pros | 🛑 Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
4. Revlon ColorStay Overtime Lipcolor (Infinite Stay Currant) 🍷
Best for 16+ Hour Wear ⏳
This is a dual-ended product: one side is the liquid color, and the other is a clear topcoat. I was skeptical, but this combo is magic. The color side feels sticky at first, but the moment you apply the clear gloss topcoat, it seals it in and feels comfortable.
I tested "Infinite Stay Currant," a beautiful berry shade. I ate a greasy slice of pizza while wearing this, and I am not joking—it looked exactly the same afterwards. It is essentially bulletproof.
| ✅ Pros | 🛑 Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
🤓 Science Nerd Corner: If you want to understand the deep chemistry behind why these dual-ended products work so well compared to single liquids, I found this incredible breakdown on how to make a liquid lipstick transfer proof that explains the film-former technology perfectly.
5. Essence 8H Matte Liquid Lipstick (Silky Hazelnut) 🌰
Best Budget Option 💸
I wasn't expecting much from this because it is so affordable, but Essence surprised me. "Silky Hazelnut" is a warm, cozy brown. It doesn't have the heavy-duty "paint" feeling of the Milani or Revlon.
It’s a moussey texture. It claims 8 hours, and I’d say I got a solid 5 hours of perfect wear before it started fading. But for the price? It is an absolute steal. It’s also much easier to remove than the others.
| ✅ Pros | 🛑 Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
The Final Comparison 📊
| Brand | Best Feature | Finish | Comfort |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maybelline | Fast Drying | Flat Matte | ⭐⭐⭐ |
| L'Oreal | Texture | Powdery Matte | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| Milani | Pigment | Ultra Matte | ⭐⭐ |
| Revlon | Longevity | Glossy/Satin | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| Essence | Price | Soft Matte | ⭐⭐⭐ |
How to Choose the Best One for You 🧭
If you have dry lips, go for the L'Oreal Infallible—it is by far the most forgiving. If you are going to a wedding and need to eat, drink, and dance without checking a mirror, buy the Revlon ColorStay. For a cheap, daily purse lipstick that gets the job done, Maybelline remains the classic choice.
👉 Read Next: If these matte options sound too heavy for you, you might prefer something lighter. I recently compared Teddy Tint vs K-Beauty lip and cheek tints which offer a much softer look!
Final Thoughts 💭
Liquid lipstick technology has come a long way. You no longer have to choose between color and comfort. Personally, I am keeping the Revlon for nights out and the L'Oreal for my daily work bag. Which one will you try?
Keep shining! ✨
Frequently Asked Questions ❓
Which lipstick stays on while eating?
In my test, the Revlon ColorStay Overtime was the clear winner. The dual-phase formula creates a seal that resists oil and grease better than standard liquid mattes.
Which type of lipstick is best for daily use?
For daily use, I recommend the L'Oreal Infallible Matte Resistance or Essence 8H Matte. They are more comfortable and lighter on the lips, making them easier to wear for 8 hours straight.
Can I use 2 year old lipstick?
Generally, liquid lipsticks expire after 12-18 months. If it smells like crayons, has separated, or the texture has become clumpy, toss it immediately! 🗑️
Which is the no. 1 lipstick?
Sales-wise, Maybelline SuperStay/Sensational lines are often global bestsellers due to price and availability. However, "No. 1" depends on your needs (comfort vs. longevity).
Last Updated: 27 December 2025
0 Comments